With all due respect, I don't think you can get much clearer than what it is now. It's almost a 20% lead with nearly 50% of all votes. It's the equivalent to Barrack Obama running against Ralph Nader for president.
-
The moderators of this forum can be found in the CAP forum staff directory.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
CAP 3 CAP 3 - Part 7 (Art Selection Poll)
- Thread starter Gothic Togekiss
- Start date
- Status
This is probably the best argument available for not doing a run-off.
Rock Head makes it broken? how please? Hell Revenankh gets Shed Skin + Rest for crying out loud. Wait lets not forget about Syclant getting Mountaineer to avoid 50 percent damage each switch in. SO Syclant can avoid 50 percent damage and not be broken, while Leonin can avoid to take minor recoil damage and yet it is broken. Hhhmm, great logic, i love it, bravo!
Yes..I'm aware. When I statement about doing a secondary poll and it satisfying people whom want a clearer cut decision, I want making a general statement. I did said that the majority shown here wanted Woodman to win and that a second poll isn't all that needed here.
Calm yourself and read. I said Rock Head is an ability that isn't broken.
But wow, way to go ballistic on something that wasn't even said. Bravo.
Not really. Just arguments for and against Elagune's "Woodman" and Catoons!'s Elk.
I love that picture, but you're a bit late here.
If you had submitted that before this poll, I so would have voted for it.
If you had submitted that before this poll, I so would have voted for it.
Well, there's 60 people who's votes are basically null and void. If enough of those people would have voted for Cartoon's, then a majority actually wouldn't have been appeased.
First of all, why exactly are they null and void?
Secondly, if that were true, then it would be closer, but the fact is, those people didn't vote for Cartoons!'s. Hypothetically, if all the people that didn't vote for Woodman had voted for the Elk, then it would have won, but they didn't so it doesn't matter.
And what would be the odds of, out of 59 voters, at least 53 of them would vote for the Elk? Not very high.
And I agree with Tsukikage (Moon Shadow?), saying null and void isn't the best way to phrase that statement.
Winning isn't really why I made a new drawing of my concept. Frankly, I was so embarassed about how the first turned out I had to make it up to myself.
Honestly though, I thought more peope would have liked the idea of a western-style chile pepper. I guess the stats didn't really suit him (he looks a little more physical than special).
Actually, I really liked the first drawing, and I think it would have fit our Pokemon very well!
It's just that, after seeing the race between Cartoons! and Elagune, I decided I had to help out the underdog of that race. x( (That and I was disappointed about the whole Gentle Giant incident.)
It's just that, after seeing the race between Cartoons! and Elagune, I decided I had to help out the underdog of that race. x( (That and I was disappointed about the whole Gentle Giant incident.)
Okay, on the redo-ing the polls to see who really won:
Whoever starts to win in the first few hours of the first poll usually wins. Running off options really only mattered once, on Syclant's Base Stats (+/- 2 votes for the front runners). Unless another poll is that close, I'm starting to think we don't need secondary polls.
I for one voted for CyzirVisheen's chilimonster. I would vote for the Cannon dude. The 60 odd people who did not vote for the front runners are 25% of the total. .........................
I don't know where I'm going with that, but the point still stands. The front runner has won all follow up polls, except for when it is too close for there to be a front runner (within 5 votes of each other).
Whoever starts to win in the first few hours of the first poll usually wins. Running off options really only mattered once, on Syclant's Base Stats (+/- 2 votes for the front runners). Unless another poll is that close, I'm starting to think we don't need secondary polls.
I for one voted for CyzirVisheen's chilimonster. I would vote for the Cannon dude. The 60 odd people who did not vote for the front runners are 25% of the total. .........................
I don't know where I'm going with that, but the point still stands. The front runner has won all follow up polls, except for when it is too close for there to be a front runner (within 5 votes of each other).
Is it just me or does the Woodman's percentage slowly (VERY slowly) decrease every few minutes? :S
@ Hyra: Elagune's drawing (Woodman), got a huge amount of its votes in the first hour, putting far ahead of the others, so...
@ Dane: Didn't notice. :x I'm really only paying attention to Elagune's votes at this point.
@ Hyra: Elagune's drawing (Woodman), got a huge amount of its votes in the first hour, putting far ahead of the others, so...
@ Dane: Didn't notice. :x I'm really only paying attention to Elagune's votes at this point.
It's the government! I knew it all along!:chaos:
i really think a second poll is in order...
woodman vs. stag. plain and simple.
its less than an 18 point difference at the moment...it's worth another poll. especially since this poll came so soon, give cartoons and elagune a day to come up with a more finalized art if they want, then shoot it into a poll. that way there's no bickering.
this has been the most bicker-ridden project yet. and that's in no way GT's fault. it's the democratic process.
woodman vs. stag. plain and simple.
its less than an 18 point difference at the moment...it's worth another poll. especially since this poll came so soon, give cartoons and elagune a day to come up with a more finalized art if they want, then shoot it into a poll. that way there's no bickering.
this has been the most bicker-ridden project yet. and that's in no way GT's fault. it's the democratic process.
A poll is a poll; I don't think it needs to be redone. The best thing is just to move on and keep on walking, one foot forward at a time. The current winner, Woodman, is pretty clear-cut as it stands and it would be a huge disservice to them to take a perfectly fair and legit poll and throw it out so someone else can win. I would be pissed if I was Elagune and had my shoes taken out right from under me. This isn't Florida, there are no hanging chads, and if people felt bad about how they voted -- they can take a good lesson from this and vote when they are...
...more sure about their decision?
Bleh, I'm sure you get what I'm saying.
...more sure about their decision?
Bleh, I'm sure you get what I'm saying.
I havent really participated in this project but i have been readin the posts and voted for cartoons...i think the deer deserves to win and this is why:
-it looks more defensive(specially the 2nd one)
-its original(the idea of a fire bambi is just to great lol)
this is why i dont like woodman so much:
-its style for some reason it dosnt seem like a pokemon but then again is like a fire grovyle in cannons
-it looks to ofensive and more to the physical side
-I actually think woodman will be faster even than the deer because of its fire looking cannnons that look like it can charge him on
-woodman was posted first than cartoons and alot of people just take the idea of seeing an awsome well drawen pokemon without taking in consideration other designs and how much the stats coordinate with the art
voted cartoons
-it looks more defensive(specially the 2nd one)
-its original(the idea of a fire bambi is just to great lol)
this is why i dont like woodman so much:
-its style for some reason it dosnt seem like a pokemon but then again is like a fire grovyle in cannons
-it looks to ofensive and more to the physical side
-I actually think woodman will be faster even than the deer because of its fire looking cannnons that look like it can charge him on
-woodman was posted first than cartoons and alot of people just take the idea of seeing an awsome well drawen pokemon without taking in consideration other designs and how much the stats coordinate with the art
voted cartoons
- Status