NOC Lovers Dance Mafia Game Thread: Game Over, Scum Win!

It's weird that even though there's no nightkills we're just thinking about this as purely a numbers game? At least that's the impression you would get reading ap's posts although he himself would probably admit that his reads drive a large part of his plan forward.

Which is why I am suspicious of him. A game without nightkills means that it's massively more important for the mafia to control the lynch. I don't think they can be content to idle and hope that things work out. When you think about the kind of players in the game, I think everyone (who has a little experience on smogon) would agree on the one user who would probably make the effort to control the lynch. ap's plan then just strikes me as being dangerous because of how it asks everyone to give up on critically thinking about the game (which is i guess what we're already doing heh). like #145 is just such an emotional post that doesn't just stay emotional but goes into the realm of extreme/irrational/black and white thought that I can't help but feel that something's up.

I thought ken had a post where he said he thought there was no incentive to post but i misread it. was going to say he was mafia but any further thoughts on him only have the justification of him trying to get people to post without doing it himself. unfort

texas's post reads pretty lazy in terms of a justification to vote apricity but that's all I really have. I actually think this setup is fairly interesting when we're not just afking away lol. I am to blame for that too I suppose!
 
i'm on board with inferno i think, it didnt make any sense to me that apricity would peg them as scum on d1 and even less sense that he'd want to pair me off with someone he thought was scummy rather than try to read me. could be scumpricity trying to take an easy out on me maybe? but even thats less weird than setting up inferno as a lynch today. with that and after talking with inferno it just doesnt any sense to me for them to be scum

idk if that means apricity is scum or not but if he's town if i'm understanding his lynch path correctly our only lose condition is apricity actually being scum himself. seeing as we have one mislynch to give it seems to me that the optimal play then is to lynch apricity and validate his alignment, if he's scum then we avoid the railroad from the player trying the hardest and if he does end up being town then he's still left us a road map to win by following his plan and lynching inferno, and then kens pairing

one thing i dont understand the full reasoning for from your plan apricity, why are we pairing people off with the same couples consistently? i understand the value of tying alignments to each other but when i was signing up for the game i thought that the most strategic part would be using the progressive neighbourhoods to filter reads

vote apricity
you're braindead again, can we skip this phase of the game and just get to the part where you start sheeping my reads please

lynching me doesn't work because then we don't get to 4p lylo guaranteed by lynching scum gentleman ahhhhhhh what's WRONG with you
 
you're braindead again, can we skip this phase of the game and just get to the part where you start sheeping my reads please
Dude, there are other opinions besides yours that need to be taken into account. Honestly, this type of insistence and defensiveness goes beyond what even you normally do and just cements my argument for why you are scum
 
hey guys

hal rlly is lock town

stop it
What makes you so convinced of this? Hal has done nothing but randomly accuse people with absolutely no evidence to back it up. I really don’t understand why you would be backing them. The only outlandish situation other than that he has successfully brainwashed you is that you are the maf in the relationship, which I see as highly unlikely. The fact you are still defending them just confuses me
 
What makes you so convinced of this? Hal has done nothing but randomly accuse people with absolutely no evidence to back it up. I really don’t understand why you would be backing them. The only outlandish situation other than that he has successfully brainwashed you is that you are the maf in the relationship, which I see as highly unlikely. The fact you are still defending them just confuses me
read his posts again but this time dont hyper focus on misslynching a town
 

Duskfall98

Votecount Specialist
is a Forum Moderator
Moderator
Ok before anyone says that I'm just hopping on a wagon I'm just gonna point out that in lovers chat I told ken I thought hal was given way more town credit than he deserved. I agree with inferno that he could easily have put himself in a position to control the pairings because he has no lynch.

The plan kinda failed anyway because we didn't end up pairing anyone scummy, we voted 2 neutrals we had no info on at all and since the pairing inferno has come off as so innocent that he's never lynched here.

I don't know who decided hal should have the power to pair anyway? I understood the agreement as a group deciding two scum reads to put together and then everyone else deciding for themselves. We put way too much power into one person's hands, serious misplay imo.

Now as I also said to ken in lovers chat viper sheep's hal regularly but this game it seems even more forced than usual. He literally just hopped in and said he's going to sheep hal all game and since then done nothing but defend him without logic. Things like 'Hal's clear town get off' is stupid, he can't even come with up a reasoning.

So yeah I'm nearly 100 percent sure there's at least one scum in the hal viper pair, between the likelihood of hal trying to control vote or the fact that if hal is town viper is probably trying to pocket. As long as we get one now it should be easy to get into the 4 person lylo with 1 scum and clynch the win.

Vote hal/viper
 
Ok before anyone says that I'm just hopping on a wagon I'm just gonna point out that in lovers chat I told ken I thought hal was given way more town credit than he deserved. I agree with inferno that he could easily have put himself in a position to control the pairings because he has no lynch.

The plan kinda failed anyway because we didn't end up pairing anyone scummy, we voted 2 neutrals we had no info on at all and since the pairing inferno has come off as so innocent that he's never lynched here.

I don't know who decided hal should have the power to pair anyway? I understood the agreement as a group deciding two scum reads to put together and then everyone else deciding for themselves. We put way too much power into one person's hands, serious misplay imo.

Now as I also said to ken in lovers chat viper sheep's hal regularly but this game it seems even more forced than usual. He literally just hopped in and said he's going to sheep hal all game and since then done nothing but defend him without logic. Things like 'Hal's clear town get off' is stupid, he can't even come with up a reasoning.

So yeah I'm nearly 100 percent sure there's at least one scum in the hal viper pair, between the likelihood of hal trying to control vote or the fact that if hal is town viper is probably trying to pocket. As long as we get one now it should be easy to get into the 4 person lylo with 1 scum and clynch the win.

Vote hal/viper
his posts have been bleeding town

hal has a very defined player meta

tone is towny

we didnt decide hal had power to plan because we were all inactive, hal legit pushed us in the right direction here because no1 else was

i cant be the only one seeing this lol
 
please for every1 in the game

reread hals interactions with dusk and mindset when he was posting the solves

then if you still dont get it talk to me rather than building up this mindless wagon w/ scum on it
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 1, Guests: 0)

Top