-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Mafia vs Village Companions Mafia [POSTGAME]
- Thread starter Blazade
- Start date
DEADLINE
You wake up, wondering what tragedy may have befallen the camp last night. The results are pretty grim.
The first body you find belonged to Hitmonleet
But the Red Team wasn't the only team to suffer a great loss. MoodyCloud was found dead as well
Will the Blue Team survive such losses? Can the lynch find its mark? Only time will tell.
Results are going out, do not post without my confirmation
You wake up, wondering what tragedy may have befallen the camp last night. The results are pretty grim.
The first body you find belonged to Hitmonleet
At the loss of her partner, Concrete Man was forced to lay down for a final rest
With that, all roles Hitmonleet controls are dead, and Hitmonleet is removed from the game.
But the Red Team wasn't the only team to suffer a great loss. MoodyCloud was found dead as well
Stricken with grief, Top Man didn't know what to do! She didn't have to ponder the subject for long, though...
With that, all roles MoodyCloud controls are dead, and MoodyCloud is removed from the game.
Will the Blue Team survive such losses? Can the lynch find its mark? Only time will tell.
Results are going out, do not post without my confirmation
Last edited:
An ally to our cause has given us a lead that this man may in fact be a member of the devious illuminati that threatens both the world of communism and capitalism.
He was then presented a chance to claim and assert his innocence in which he then decided he would rather not. So this is the next step towards a proper revolution.
He was then presented a chance to claim and assert his innocence in which he then decided he would rather not. So this is the next step towards a proper revolution.
Vote THE SCIATIC NERVE
lol
Anyways. I do really want to point out something big. Claiming is absolutely necessary
In this game, town has so few resources towards clearing people or outing scum.
1. No faction checking
2. All inspect roles get only a fraction of roles unless two factions can coordinate to working together (requiring blue team to either organize or the blue team inspector to get in contact with me or pidge somehow).
3. Trackers and watchers are nice. But they can't really do much unless we know the role someone claimed and the actions they supposedly used.
What this means is that when you are being suspected, you absolutely have to at least claim something. Because of the nature of alias roles, you should be free to at least claim that without fear of being caught. However what Jalmont is doing right now is incredibly awful as it gives no way to either clear him or assign guilt. So we can only go with the guilt option.
For more details as to why Jalmont was specifically singled out. Last night a role was used that targets two people. Those two people then receive the others alias. Neither of the people targeted knew about this in advanced and yet one of them brought it up without needing to, confirming it worked. Jalmont was one of the targets of this. However upon asking Jalmont for any night results and subsequently pressuring him he refused to mention he had obtained another players alias. He did eventually confirm this to the player himself after "some specific probe".
But what is clear. He was not sharing this information. There is 0 cause to not even mention this to the people trying to organize the faction you claimed to be. So the most obvious conclusion becomes he was attempting to hide knowing the alias so it couldn't be connected back to him if that player's alias died.
Anyways. I do really want to point out something big. Claiming is absolutely necessary
In this game, town has so few resources towards clearing people or outing scum.
1. No faction checking
2. All inspect roles get only a fraction of roles unless two factions can coordinate to working together (requiring blue team to either organize or the blue team inspector to get in contact with me or pidge somehow).
3. Trackers and watchers are nice. But they can't really do much unless we know the role someone claimed and the actions they supposedly used.
What this means is that when you are being suspected, you absolutely have to at least claim something. Because of the nature of alias roles, you should be free to at least claim that without fear of being caught. However what Jalmont is doing right now is incredibly awful as it gives no way to either clear him or assign guilt. So we can only go with the guilt option.
For more details as to why Jalmont was specifically singled out. Last night a role was used that targets two people. Those two people then receive the others alias. Neither of the people targeted knew about this in advanced and yet one of them brought it up without needing to, confirming it worked. Jalmont was one of the targets of this. However upon asking Jalmont for any night results and subsequently pressuring him he refused to mention he had obtained another players alias. He did eventually confirm this to the player himself after "some specific probe".
But what is clear. He was not sharing this information. There is 0 cause to not even mention this to the people trying to organize the faction you claimed to be. So the most obvious conclusion becomes he was attempting to hide knowing the alias so it couldn't be connected back to him if that player's alias died.
you have just provided a very circular argument as to why claiming is "absolutely necessary" because you can make literally the exact same case except in a game where town has plenty of resources towards cleaning people
1. not an argument
2. ok why dont u coordinate with the other faction instead of bothering me
3. you think trackers and watchers are ineffective unless you have all the claims which is objectively not true.
then you provide a nonsense argument about how i should claim because "aliases" which doesn't make sense especially given that you already know my alias or at least can learn it pretty easily lol.
like i said, i'm not sharing any information with you because i see 0 reason why i should share any information with you. you have accomplished nothing for the red team in this game and are likely responsible for losing our bg (of which only one kill was used to do so :thinking:) I mean no disrespect to hitmonleet but you're out of ur mind if you think someone would decide to rand hitmonleet over pidge, you, da letter el, zorbees, me, etc. so why don't you come up with some reasons why anyone should trust you? or you can provide the "evidence" that i'm mafia.
1. not an argument
2. ok why dont u coordinate with the other faction instead of bothering me
3. you think trackers and watchers are ineffective unless you have all the claims which is objectively not true.
then you provide a nonsense argument about how i should claim because "aliases" which doesn't make sense especially given that you already know my alias or at least can learn it pretty easily lol.
like i said, i'm not sharing any information with you because i see 0 reason why i should share any information with you. you have accomplished nothing for the red team in this game and are likely responsible for losing our bg (of which only one kill was used to do so :thinking:) I mean no disrespect to hitmonleet but you're out of ur mind if you think someone would decide to rand hitmonleet over pidge, you, da letter el, zorbees, me, etc. so why don't you come up with some reasons why anyone should trust you? or you can provide the "evidence" that i'm mafia.
I would love to coordinate with blue team. But that requires them to stop trying to lose.
While 3 is semi true. that's not at all what I said. Rather, trackers and watchers in this case can only find a guilty if they catch the person doing the killing which has very poor odds even in a game like this. Whereas when there are claims they can catch people who have lied about their actions or their targets for nights.
And generally yes. When someone who is trying to lead the faction you claim you are on asks you if you had any notable results. And you do, then chose to not even mention it. That's a major red flag.
For your last reason, that's total crap and you know it. You are straight up implying that it's possible to solve the game and catch mafia when refusing to claim anything about your role and lack of good inspects. I am trying my damnest to catch mafia but that's only possible with coordination and information sharing - something everyone has been very very conservative this game.
Lastly, you are completely out of your mind if you think Leet told me he was a vig and then as a mole, I wouldn't proceed to abuse it. Hell, what you are implying is that Leet told me about his death condition and the rest of his role - requiring a bunch of trust - and then I proceded to kill someone who would be willing to protect my alias and who could kill people I wanted killed.
Also since I can't imagine it's much of a secret to everyone but blue team. The kill on moody was leet. He had protected that alias N0 and then N1 I went around asking everyone who had claimed red team if they were one of those 3 aliases. Yourself included. Moody and you were the only two who refused to answer. Meanwhile Leet decided to do the kill and I was growing apathic to this game so I didn't try hard to stop him.
So yes obviously as scum I kill off the vig who is actively working with me for direction and willing to protect my vulnerable alias.
Vastly more likely is that Leet got randed with an inspection N0 and they proceed to kill him.
Further more. It's already been clearly established that village has roles that die when only one name is killed. Both leet and moody are examples of this. I straight up claimed this property N0 before any flips and claims have gone out. If you seriously think I'm mafia you are absolutely insane.
While 3 is semi true. that's not at all what I said. Rather, trackers and watchers in this case can only find a guilty if they catch the person doing the killing which has very poor odds even in a game like this. Whereas when there are claims they can catch people who have lied about their actions or their targets for nights.
And generally yes. When someone who is trying to lead the faction you claim you are on asks you if you had any notable results. And you do, then chose to not even mention it. That's a major red flag.
For your last reason, that's total crap and you know it. You are straight up implying that it's possible to solve the game and catch mafia when refusing to claim anything about your role and lack of good inspects. I am trying my damnest to catch mafia but that's only possible with coordination and information sharing - something everyone has been very very conservative this game.
Lastly, you are completely out of your mind if you think Leet told me he was a vig and then as a mole, I wouldn't proceed to abuse it. Hell, what you are implying is that Leet told me about his death condition and the rest of his role - requiring a bunch of trust - and then I proceded to kill someone who would be willing to protect my alias and who could kill people I wanted killed.
Also since I can't imagine it's much of a secret to everyone but blue team. The kill on moody was leet. He had protected that alias N0 and then N1 I went around asking everyone who had claimed red team if they were one of those 3 aliases. Yourself included. Moody and you were the only two who refused to answer. Meanwhile Leet decided to do the kill and I was growing apathic to this game so I didn't try hard to stop him.
So yes obviously as scum I kill off the vig who is actively working with me for direction and willing to protect my vulnerable alias.
Vastly more likely is that Leet got randed with an inspection N0 and they proceed to kill him.
Further more. It's already been clearly established that village has roles that die when only one name is killed. Both leet and moody are examples of this. I straight up claimed this property N0 before any flips and claims have gone out. If you seriously think I'm mafia you are absolutely insane.
hi i'm blue so talk to me if you're blue, too.
Unvote, Vote Haruno
Haruno has claimed he is a twin and on the blue team. This presents an obvious problem as that's 1. The easiest mafia role in the world to claim
2. Does not explain why either he or his supposed twin didnt try to lead blue team.
3. A majority of blue team claimers backed his lynch.
All put together this seems like a surefire lynch. However if there does exist a mason to haruno, speak now or forever hold your peace.
2. Does not explain why either he or his supposed twin didnt try to lead blue team.
3. A majority of blue team claimers backed his lynch.
All put together this seems like a surefire lynch. However if there does exist a mason to haruno, speak now or forever hold your peace.
vote jalmont
Unvote, Vote Jalmont okay then.